I am writing this text on Sunday afternoon and scheduling it to be printed on Monday at 2 am PST. The Emmys air on Sunday evening, just some hours from now as I kind this.
By the point you learn this, you’ll know whether or not or not Noah Wyle went house with an Emmy for his work on the hit HBO Max collection “The Pitt.” Noah has two possibilities to convey house an Emmy. As an actor, he is nominated within the Excellent Lead Actor in a Drama Collection class. As an government producer, he is nominated for Excellent Drama Collection.
If he does win, the victory can be considerably bittersweet. Despite the fact that “The Pitt” is a big success and producing a considerably surprising later-career resurgence, Noah and the creators/studio behind the present are presently embroiled in an ungainly and probably very expensive lawsuit. On the coronary heart of the dispute is Michael Crichton, one of the crucial profitable tv, e book, and movie creators of all time.
Frederick M. Brown/Getty Photographs
The Lawsuit
As you most likely know, Noah Wyle turned a family title within the Nineteen Nineties because of his function as Dr. John Carter on Michael Crichton’s NBC hospital drama “ER.” What you could not know is that “ER” itself was the brainchild of Crichton — one of many uncommon creators whose affect spanned literature, movie, and tv.
Truly, let’s step again a second.
From Medical Scholar to Jurassic Park
Michael Crichton started his profession not in Hollywood, however in drugs. A Harvard Medical Faculty graduate, he began writing novels as a facet hustle whereas nonetheless in coaching. His early works, typically printed underneath pseudonyms, paid his payments but additionally revealed his fascination with the intersection of science, know-how, and human vulnerability. That theme turned his hallmark.
In 1969, Crichton printed “The Andromeda Pressure,” a novel a few lethal extraterrestrial virus. It was a runaway bestseller, tailored into successful movie two years later. All of the sudden, Crichton was not simply a health care provider dabbling in fiction — he was a brand new drive in American popular culture.
All through the Seventies and Nineteen Eighties, he turned one of many world’s best-selling authors, turning out books like “Congo,” “Sphere,” and “Rising Solar.” He additionally stepped behind the digicam, writing and directing the 1973 sci-fi thriller “Westworld.” The movie’s premise — a theme park populated by malfunctioning androids — would echo by way of popular culture for many years, ultimately inspiring HBO’s big-budget collection of the identical title.
Then got here the breakthrough that outlined his legacy: “Jurassic Park.” First a 1990 novel, then a 1993 Steven Spielberg movie, the story turned a world phenomenon, grossing greater than $1 billion and turning Crichton right into a family title. By the early Nineteen Nineties, he was a novelist whose books offered tons of of tens of millions of copies, a filmmaker with cult classics on his résumé, and a Hollywood insider working alongside the trade’s strongest names.
From “Emergency Ward” to “ER”
Because it turned out, again in 1974, Crichton had drawn on his personal experiences as a medical scholar to write down a screenplay known as “EW,” brief for “Emergency Ward.” The script was a real-time story a few single day inside a chaotic hospital emergency room. With encouragement from his highly effective agent, Michael Ovitz, Crichton started buying the mission to networks.
For years, it went nowhere. However within the early Nineteen Nineties, as Spielberg’s Amblin Leisure was using excessive from the success of “Jurassic Park,” the concept resurfaced. Amblin and Warner Bros. backed a two-hour pilot, retitled “ER.” To information the mission on the tv facet, Warner introduced in John Wells, a rising writer-producer who had simply completed a celebrated run on the Vietnam hospital drama “China Seaside.” Wells turned ER’s government producer and eventual showrunner, shaping the tone, pacing, and longevity of the collection.
The “ER” Juggernaut
When “ER” debuted on NBC in September 1994, it exploded right into a phenomenon. Slotted into the community’s coveted Thursday evening “Should See TV” lineup alongside “Buddies” and “Seinfeld,” the present captivated audiences with its breathless tempo, unflinching realism, and sophisticated ensemble forged. Viewers tuned in not only for the medical emergencies, however for the intertwining private dramas of docs and nurses working on the fictional County Normal Hospital in Chicago.
The forged turned family names nearly in a single day. George Clooney broke out as pediatrician Doug Ross. Julianna Margulies received acclaim as nurse Carol Hathaway. And Noah Wyle, as fresh-faced med scholar John Carter, offered the viewers’s entry level into the chaos. Crichton’s imaginative and prescient — that drugs must be portrayed with out sugarcoating, in all its depth and ethical ambiguity — was realized on display.
Critics and audiences responded. “ER” ran for an astonishing 15 seasons and 331 episodes, making it the longest-running primetime medical drama till it was ultimately surpassed by “Gray’s Anatomy.” The present received 23 Primetime Emmy Awards and was nominated for greater than 120. At its peak, it drew over 30 million viewers per week.
It was additionally a monetary juggernaut. Syndication offers, DVD gross sales, and later streaming rights generated greater than $3.5 billion for Warner Bros. Tv.
OK, Again to the Lawsuit
Three many years after “ER” first aired, Noah Wyle discovered himself circling again to the function that made his profession. In early 2020, he emailed John Wells — his outdated “ER” showrunner — with an concept: a darker, extra intimate restricted collection that revisited Dr. John Carter years later, scarred and aged, however nonetheless within the trenches of emergency drugs.
Warner Bros. Tv cherished the concept, and negotiations started with Sherri Crichton, Michael’s widow and the executor of his property. Draft press releases have been even written asserting an “ER” sequel. However then issues fell aside. Sherri found a key clause in Michael’s unique contracts: a “frozen rights” provision requiring her approval for any “ER” sequel, spinoff, or reboot. With out her sign-off, the deal could not go ahead.
The standoff was particularly fraught as a result of the Crichton property already felt burned by Warner and its sister firm HBO. When HBO revived Michael’s 1973 movie “Westworld” as a status collection in 2016, the studio declined to provide Crichton a coveted “Created By” credit score, as a substitute itemizing him solely as “Based mostly on characters created by.” For Sherri and the property, that was greater than a matter of ego — creator credit carry vital monetary weight. It left them cautious that Warner may as soon as once more revenue off Crichton’s concepts with out correctly honoring his function.
Slightly than scrap the mission completely, Warner Bros. retooled it. Wyle would nonetheless star, Wells would nonetheless produce, and the format would nonetheless echo Crichton’s unique “one shift” imaginative and prescient. However the brand new collection can be set in Pittsburgh as a substitute of Chicago, with Wyle taking part in Dr. Michael Robinavitch as a substitute of Dr. John Carter. The mission was renamed “The Pitt.”
From Warner’s perspective, this was a brand-new present. From the Crichton property’s perspective, it was “ER” in disguise. In August 2024, the property filed a lawsuit in Los Angeles Superior Court docket, accusing Warner Bros., Wyle, Wells, and showrunner R. Scott Gemmill of breaching Crichton’s contracts and violating his mental property.
What may need remained a behind-the-scenes negotiation as a substitute erupted into a really public conflict, simply as “The Pitt” was incomes rave critiques — and Emmy nominations. And within the course of, the lawsuit pulled again the curtain on monetary particulars about “ER” that had by no means been public earlier than.
The Monetary Bombshell
If not for this lawsuit, the general public may by no means have identified simply how helpful “ER” was for Michael Crichton’s property. As we talked about earlier, Warner Bros. has made no less than $3.5 billion from the collection by way of its 15-season run and lengthy after, because of syndication, DVD gross sales, and streaming rights.
And the Crichton property’s precise lawsuit courtroom filings give us much more element. In accordance with the lawsuit, Michael’s 1994 contract assured him:
- $7,500 per-episode royalty tied to his “Created By” credit score
- $35,000–$40,000 producer price per episode, escalating after season one
- A 50/50 share of merchandising income (with Amblin) after breakeven
- 17.5% share of Adjusted Gross Earnings, one of many richest backend offers ever granted to a TV creator
These first two bullet factors, the upfront charges, alone labored out to about $47,500 per episode by the mid-run of the collection. Throughout 331 episodes, that is roughly $16 million in baseline royalties and producer checks. I doubt ER merchandise was a significant quantity. Have you ever ever seen anybody carrying an ER hat or shirt? Not even on the peak of the present’s recognition. In order that leaves that fourth bullet level, the 17.5% backend “Adjusted Gross Earnings.” In different phrases, Crichton’s property owned 17.5% of the present’s fairness.
In accordance with the lawsuit and the property’s legal professionals, that backend finally paid out the equal of about $800,000 per episode — income tied to syndication, worldwide gross sales, and streaming. Multiply that by 331 episodes and also you get…
$264,800,000
And whenever you add the $16 million he made whereas the present was being produced, that brings Crichton’s complete ER windfall to…
$280,800,000
It is one of many largest creator payouts in tv historical past. BUT, as eye-popping as that $264.8 million ER windfall is, keep in mind – it was only one pillar of Michael Crichton’s exceptional profession. Over the course of 4 many years, his 29 novels offered greater than 250 million copies worldwide, making him one of many best-selling authors in historical past. On the massive display, variations of his work — from “Jurassic Park” and “The Misplaced World” to “Congo,” “Sphere,” and “Disclosure” — have generated tens of billions in field workplace, DVD, and streaming income, with “Jurassic Park” alone spawning one of many highest-grossing movie franchises of all time. As a director, he left his mark with “Westworld,” a cult basic that many years later turned a status HBO collection.
Taken collectively, books, movies, tv, and even his celebrated artwork assortment constructed an property value tons of of tens of millions. The lawsuit over ‘The Pitt’ might have revealed the true scale of Crichton’s ‘ER’ royalties, however within the larger image, it is a reminder: Michael Crichton was by no means only a novelist, or only a filmmaker, or simply the creator of successful TV present. He was all of them — and his legacy continues to form popular culture and Hollywood steadiness sheets, lengthy after his loss of life. And now, that legacy is being examined in courtroom.
If Noah did win final evening, it could be a very bittersweet second. If he misplaced, it is double bitter.
