The highway to success in manga and anime isn’t a easy one, and Eiichiro Oda’s One Piece is about as clear an instance as attainable. The world-renowned franchise has generated billions due to Oda’s ingenuity and tireless dedication to creating manga’s most epic journey. Regardless of this success, One Piece’s earliest days had some notable failures.
Past Oda’s notion of his one-shots not taking off as a younger artist, One Piece had its blueprint buried inside its earliest iterations, being each variations of Romance Daybreak. Featured in each Weekly Shonen Soar 1996 Summer season Particular and mainline Weekly Shonen Soar, Oda’s Shonen Jump debut fell flat in his eyes. Every launch, nevertheless, constructed up his final story.
One Piece’s Prototypes Are Predictably Tough But Entertaining
Studying by each variations of Romance Daybreak, it was clear that Oda needed to render an journey on the excessive seas. Oda spoke of the expertise as “complete chaos”, being concurrently grateful to his fellow assistants for serving to him full it in time, however hardly seeing the ultimate end result, launched in Weekly Shonen Soar, as superb.
This interview with the creator, featured within the October 3, 2025 version of One Piece Journal, laid out Oda’s overview of the manufacturing’s outcomes. Given a two-week deadline to attract a one-shot from scratch, Oda reworked his present model of Romance Daybreak, however as a substitute of the Summer season Particular for up-and-comers, this was the big-leagues. Oda knew the stakes at hand.
It was complete chaos, so I do not bear in mind the outcomes in any respect. What mattered extra was the reduction that someway we prevented leaving a gap in Soar. That mentioned, I spotted that alternatives actually can come out of nowhere, and you will need to have a agency conviction to utterly seize that second.
From there, I started developing with the serialization identify “One Piece.” Although it was rejected just a few instances in the course of the serialization conferences, lastly, one yr later, the serialization of 1 piece started.
-Eiichiro Oda
The outcomes of every endeavor are predictably tough. One can simply spot the extra intriguing One Piece components in Romance Daybreak model 1, particularly the looks of Shanks, the Conqueror’s Haki, and Shanks giving Luffy his straw hat. Model 2 can also be noteworthy for deliberately swapping out Shanks for Luffy’s grandfather, who could be recreated as Garp in One Piece.
Nonetheless, every model is laughable at elements. Model 1 options Luffy’s skiff, the Märchen, adorned with 4 flags stacked atop one another. Model 2’s straw hat retcon as Luffy’s grandfather’s turns the dear hat right into a generic heirloom. Each variations push “Peace-Predominant” pirates as Luffy’s superb, as if he is role-playing in a pirate-themed Overwatch clone.
Regardless of these flaws, every model present innate promise, and proof of Oda’s effervescent creativeness. Every model incorporates a totally different villain, from Crescent Moon Gally’s generic-looking pirate captain in model 1, to Spiel the Hexagon’s sorcerer spin beating Black Clover’s Yuno to the punch by standing cooly whereas driving his flying broomstick. Each even feature ostensibly a proto-Nami saving Luffy’s life.
Each variations of Romance Daybreak are competently drawn, even when model 2 would not really feel prefer it feels narratively satisfying, however fairly, a prologue to one thing higher. Oda himself indicated this, calling model 1 “an excessive amount of of a One Piece prototype” in VIZ Media’s launch of his one-shot assortment, Wished!: Eiichiro Oda Earlier than One Piece.
One Piece Is Proof an Epic Manga Wants Time to Evolve
Making a one-shot for a collection as intricate as One Piece is an immense activity. Conqueror’s Haki, as indicated in Romance Daybreak model 1 after which One Piece chapter #1, is not talked about by identify till chapter #234. Instances of Haki are scattered further beyond then earlier than characters are even correctly educated in its strategies.
Shanks’ straw hat turns into immensely important within the closing launch of One Piece, with it being handed down by Gol D. Roger first. The mysterious overarching villain Imu is even seen in possession of a similar straw hat, possibly belonging to Joy Boy, Luffy’s non secular predecessor. These are connections cast over a whole bunch of chapters and many years of writing.
The mysterious overarching villain Imu is even seen in possession of an identical straw hat, probably belonging to Pleasure Boy, Luffy’s non secular predecessor. These are connections cast over a whole bunch of chapters and many years of writing.
Romance Daybreak model 1 didn’t have the strain of time constraints or an particularly high-profile viewers, and it benefited from the relaxed expectations. The story itself reads higher, apart from awkward quirks like boat equipment or Luffy having a seemingly higher urge for food for wanton destruction. It is humorous, and retains the spirit of One Piece, however lacks ample route.
One Piece chapter #1 focuses extra on Luffy’s character basis earlier than beginning his journey, as a substitute of a group of character traits and predictable backstory interacting with the worlds of Romance Daybreak. Followers see Luffy’s previous, an prolonged take a look at his childhood, and regardless of extra of Shanks’ crew being current, followers get to know Shanks extra intimately too.
It is a frequent thread for manga creators attempting to inform a narrative they desperately need out on this planet. Earlier than the success of Golden Kamuy, creator Satoru Noda introduced his ardour for ice hockey to the world with Supinamarada! It was a industrial failure, however its ideas laid the inspiration for its acclaimed revival after Golden Kamuy with Dogsred.
Oda Is the Grasp of the Lengthy Sport With One Piece
To suppose that Oda’s failures have ended with Romance Daybreak or his earlier one-shots, is misguided at finest, and ignorant at worst. His world-building workout routines can usually really feel bloated, with the most recent Prince Loki sequence feeling particularly prolonged on high of repeated delays. Whereas the delays aren’t Oda’s fault, it may well generally really feel disengaging.
But regardless of these flaws, followers will readily admit that Oda makes use of even his low factors. One clear instance is the commonly-hated Long Ring Long Land Arc, which infamously did not do a lot for the overarching plot. However with Rocks D. Xebec utilizing the arc’s Davy Again fights and its connection to Davy Jones, it is now inextricably linked.
Davy Again Fights, first talked about in One Piece chapter #306, have been most just lately integrated in chapter #1155, a full 21 years later. The character of the competitors allowed Rocks D. Xebec to compete with different pirates and their crews, playing his roster and flag within the course of, finally successful large and bolstering his forces.
Whether or not it is the case of arcs blurring the strains of filler and canon, or irritating flashbacks, the lesson to be realized whereas studying One Piece is persistence. It is necessary for any collection, however with one spanning almost 30 years, it is price numerous Berries to the discerning sailor exploring what the New World has to supply.
One Piece is much from the creation that Romance Daybreak was. Peace-Mains and Morganeers do not exist anymore; followers can simply discern the swashbucklers from evil pirates, as Oda has nailed that distinction. His failures held kernels of creativity, permitting One Piece to evolve right into a masterpiece. The previous DNA mustn’t ever be forgotten, because it’s what made One Piece attainable.
- Created by
-
Eiichiro Oda
- First Movie
-
One Piece: The Film
