The tales of Sherlock Holmes, Arthur Conan Doyle’s iconic detective, have been tailored into many kinds – from the slapstick parody of Will Ferrell’s Holmes & Watson to the fashionable reimagining in BBC’s Sherlock, however Watson constructed a collection with out Sherlock himself. Watson used the attract of a Sherlock-adjacent world to offer CBS’s medical thriller present a stronger hook.
Different properties have sidelined Holmes, like Netflix’s Enola Holmes collection, however none have made the daring resolution to kill Sherlock earlier than the story even begins. Watson season 1 peppered in simply sufficient connections to the Sherlock oeuvre to maintain the premise related, however by no means on the expense of being a medical procedural.
Nonetheless, there’s a new character being added to the cast of Watson in season 2 which unravels the draw of the present: Robert Carlyle’s Sherlock Holmes, again from the useless. After watching Watson discover ways to stand on his personal two toes, this twist threatens to undermine the premise of the collection in Watson season 2.
Introducing Sherlock Holmes Into A Present About Watson Negates The Present’s Distinctive Twist
Till Water, No Sherlock Holmes Adaptation Has Had The Audacity To Start With Sherlock’s Loss of life
Introducing Holmes as a residing character in Watson essentially undercuts the one factor that set CBS’s take aside — its willingness to inform a post-Holmes story. For over a century, diversifications have revolved round Holmes’s eccentric genius, whether or not as a steampunk motion hero within the Robert Downey Jr. movies or as a paternal determine in latest spins like Sherlock & Daughter.
Even when sidelined, Sherlock stays current — as mentor, thriller, or fable. Watson, nevertheless, dared to start out the place each different story ends: with Holmes useless, and his accomplice pressured to maneuver ahead with out him. That premise was greater than a plot gadget — it was the present’s emotional and thematic backbone.
Watching Watson and Shinwell navigate grief, guilt, {and professional} reinvention gave the collection its distinct tone, even when the “medical thriller” format generally felt like CBS draping a Holmes IP filter over a typical procedural. Resurrecting Sherlock Holmes would erase that emotional groundwork and flatten Watson’s evolution into yet one more sidekick narrative.
Furthermore, the stress between medication and deduction was the present’s most intriguing hook. Watson solves mysteries of the physique, not the thoughts — a reversal of the normal Holmes dynamic. If Holmes returns, that stability collapses. The collection would lose its distinctive lens, as the one really contemporary motive to exist in a panorama oversaturated with Sherlock Holmes diversifications.
CBS Probably Needed To Deliver In Sherlock Holmes To Increase Rankings
Reviving Holmes In Watson Is A Determined Bid To Break Out In Season 2
Bringing Sherlock Holmes into Watson was nearly definitely a transfer pushed by desperation relatively than inventive freedom. Whereas the collection launched with an intriguing premise – a world with out Holmes that enabled Watson to open his clinic to deal with the medical mysteries of Pittsburgh – its scores shortly plateaued.
Watson barely edged out The Equalizer in viewership, and with CBS canceling Queen Latifah’s collection regardless of comparable numbers, Watson has been residing on borrowed time. The hole between the 2 was typically as slim as one-tenth of a scores level, hardly the type of margin that evokes community confidence.
Critics, in the meantime, had been cut up: some praised the emotional depth and grounded tone, whereas others dismissed it as one other formulaic procedural wrapped in Sherlockian branding. Provided that, the choice to resurrect Holmes feels much less like a daring narrative twist and extra like a Hail Mary to spice up viewers curiosity.
CBS has already seen that episodes that includes legacy characters from the Holmes universe — like Irene Adler — carried out noticeably higher than the standalone circumstances. With Moriarity’s death in season 1, killing off the universe’s most well-known villain, Watson wants extra big-name mythology to mine.
Bringing again Sherlock, even in opposition to the present’s authentic premise, gives prompt advertising energy and fan curiosity. Nevertheless it additionally suggests a inventive shortcut: as an alternative of doubling down on what made Watson distinctive, CBS seems to be betting that the oldest trick in tv — resurrecting the useless — may carry in additional constant numbers.
How Sherlock Holmes Can Make Watson Stronger (Particularly Performed By Robert Carlyle)
Watson Wants An Mental Equal (Or Higher) To Steadiness The Sequence
Bringing Sherlock Holmes into Watson may really strengthen the collection by giving it renewed focus and emotional weight with out dismantling its core premise. Watson’s grief made him compelling however directionless, and with out an mental equal, his circumstances generally lacked pressure.
Introducing Sherlock, particularly performed by Robert Carlyle, provides the present a dynamic new power whereas nonetheless centering Watson’s progress. Carlyle’s casting is impressed, as his profession has been outlined by morally ambiguous characters like Rumplestiltskin in Once Upon a Time, Franco in Trainspotting, and Don in 28 Weeks Later. That complexity suits completely into Watson’s ethical grey zone, the place everybody operates someplace between mild and shadow.
Sherlock does appear to be really alive – he’s interacting corporeally with the fridge, which leads me to imagine he’s not one other hallucination – however he doesn’t essentially must change into an ongoing fixture. If dealt with rigorously, his reintroduction can stay peripheral, preserving the narrative anchored round Watson whereas enriching it with emotional and philosophical pressure.
Holmes’ return opens deep storytelling veins: how Watson reconciles his grief with betrayal, and the way Holmes faces the son he’s by no means met, established in season 1. Fairly than undoing the premise of Watson, this model of Sherlock can act as a haunting, residing mirror — the catalyst that lastly helps Watson evolve into the hero of his personal story.
- Launch Date
-
January 26, 2025
- Showrunner
-
Craig Sweeny
- Administrators
-
Larry Teng, Bille Woodruff, Jeffrey W. Byrd, Jennifer Lynch, Kristin Lehman, Mario Van Peebles, Ron Underwood, Tara Nicole Weyr, Christine Moore, Clara Aranovich
- Writers
-
Craig Sweeny, Jason Inman, Charly Evon Simpson, Shardé Miller, Anna Mackey
-
Morris Chestnut
Dr. John Watson
-
Eve Harlow
Dr. Ingrid Derian
